Mastering 401k: Your Ultimate Guide
The American retirement system is one of the most distinctive aspects of US employment benefits, with 401(k) plans as its cornerstone. For international companies establishing operations in the United States, understanding and implementing these retirement plans represents a significant compliance obligation and a powerful tool for attracting and retaining talent. The 401(k) plan has become virtually synonymous with retirement planning in America, with over 60 million active participants and more than $7 trillion in assets.
Foreign employers entering the US market face unique challenges when navigating the complex landscape of American retirement benefits. The regulatory framework, tax implications, and administrative requirements can seem daunting, especially when overlaid with cross-border considerations. This guide aims to demystify 401(k) plans for international businesses, providing a roadmap for successful implementation while ensuring compliance with US regulations.
What are 401(k) Plans?
A 401(k) plan is a tax-advantaged, defined-contribution retirement account established by employers for their employees. Named after the Internal Revenue Code section that created it, these plans allow employees to contribute a portion of their pre-tax salary to individual accounts. The funds are then invested in a selection of investment options, typically mutual funds, to grow over time and provide income during retirement.
Several variations of 401(k) plans exist, each with distinct features designed to serve different business needs:
- Traditional 401(k) plans offer the most flexibility in design but must pass annual non-discrimination tests to ensure they don’t disproportionately benefit highly compensated employees. Contributions are made with pre-tax dollars, reducing employees’ taxable income for the year of contribution, with taxes deferred until withdrawal during retirement.
- Roth 401(k) options allow after-tax contributions, meaning employees pay taxes on the money before it enters the account. The significant advantage comes at retirement when qualified withdrawals—including all investment gains—are completely tax-free.
- Safe Harbor 401(k) plans require employers to make certain mandatory contributions for employees but are exempt from the complex non-discrimination testing that traditional plans must undergo. This simplifies administration and ensures highly compensated employees can maximize their contributions.
- SIMPLE 401(k) plans are designed for small businesses with fewer than 100 employees. They feature lower contribution limits and more straightforward administration requirements but mandate employer contributions.
One of 401(k) plans’ most attractive features is the tax advantages. For 2025, employees can contribute up to $23,500 annually (with an additional $7,500 “catch-up” contribution for those 50 or older). Employer contributions can bring the total annual additions to an employee’s account to $69,000. These contributions create immediate tax savings for employees, allowing investments to grow tax-deferred for decades.
Legal and Compliance Considerations for Foreign Companies
International companies establishing 401(k) plans must navigate a complex regulatory landscape governed primarily by two key frameworks: the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and the Internal Revenue Code.
ERISA establishes comprehensive standards for pension plans in private industry, including fiduciary responsibilities, reporting and disclosure requirements, participation and vesting provisions, and funding obligations. The Department of Labor enforces these regulations to protect plan participants and ensure plan administrators act in their best interests. Foreign employers must understand that ERISA imposes significant personal liability on plan fiduciaries—those who exercise discretionary authority over plan management or assets.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) oversees the tax aspects of retirement plans, granting them “qualified” status if they meet specific requirements. This qualification is crucial, as it enables tax-deferred growth for employees and tax deductions for employer contributions. To maintain this status, plans must adhere to numerous requirements, including:
- Non-discrimination rules ensuring benefits don’t favor highly compensated employees Coverage requirements mandating the inclusion of a minimum percentage of the workforce Contribution and compensation limits Minimum participation standards Vesting schedules for employer contributions
- The SECURE 2.0 Act, passed in late 2022, introduced significant changes to retirement plan regulations, including mandatory auto-enrollment for new plans established after December 29, 2022, increased catch-up contribution limits and provisions for emergency savings accounts within 401(k) plans. International companies must stay current with these evolving requirements.
- Form 5500, an annual report filed jointly with the IRS and Department of Labor, represents another compliance obligation. This comprehensive disclosure document details the plan’s financial condition, investments, and operations. Late or incomplete filings can result in substantial penalties.
Setting Up a 401(k) Plan as an International Employer
Establishing a 401(k) plan involves several key steps and decisions. Foreign companies must establish a US legal entity, typically a subsidiary corporation or limited liability company, to sponsor the plan. Alternatively, companies can utilize an Employer of Record (EOR) service like Foothold America, which allows international businesses to hire US employees without establishing their own legal entity. Through our EOR services, foreign companies can offer competitive 401(k) plans to their U.S. workforce while we handle the legal sponsorship, administration, and compliance obligations.
When evaluating providers, international companies should consider several factors: fee structures (administrative fees and investment expenses), investment options, technology platforms, compliance support, and experience working with foreign-owned businesses. Many providers now offer specialized services for international companies, including multi-language support and guidance on cross-border issues.
Plan design decisions represent the next major step. These include:
- Eligibility requirements – determining which employees can participate based on age, service period, and job classification Contribution structure – whether and how much the employer will match employee contributions or make non-elective contributions Vesting schedule – the timeline for employees to gain ownership of the employer contributions Investment options – the range of funds available to participants Loan provisions – whether employees can borrow from their accounts Hardship withdrawal conditions – circumstances under which employees can access funds before retirement
- For plans established after December 29, 2022, the SECURE 2.0 Act mandates automatic enrollment at a rate of at least 3% of salary, with automatic annual increases of 1% until reaching at least 10% but no more than 15%. While this represents an additional administrative requirement, research shows that auto-enrollment dramatically increases participation rates.
- The plan must be formalized through a written document outlining all key provisions and procedures. This legal document is the foundation for plan operation and must be carefully drafted to ensure compliance with all applicable regulations. Many providers offer standardized documents that can be customized to meet specific needs.
- Finally, the plan must be communicated to employees through summary plan descriptions and enrollment materials. Providing these materials in multiple languages for international companies with diverse workforces can improve understanding and participation.
Eligibility of Foreign Nationals and Non-US Residents
The participation of foreign nationals in US 401(k) plans presents unique considerations. Eligibility generally depends on US income tax status rather than citizenship or immigration status.
US citizens and permanent residents (green card holders) can fully participate in 401(k) plans without special restrictions. Foreign nationals working in the US on temporary visas such as H-1B, L-1, or E visas are also typically eligible if they receive US source income reported on Form W-2 and are subject to US income taxation. However, their participation may be complicated by visa duration limitations and uncertainty about long-term US employment.
The situation becomes more complex for non-resident aliens—individuals who aren’t US citizens or permanent residents and don’t meet the substantial presence test. While technically eligible if they have US source income subject to US income tax, their participation raises additional considerations:
- Tax treaties between the US and their home countries may affect taxation of contributions and distributions Withdrawals may be subject to special withholding requirements Investment gains might face taxation in both countries. Future distributions could create tax complications if the individual has returned to their home country
- For employees who split their time between the US and other countries, determining eligibility requires careful analysis of their tax residency status and the source of their compensation. In some cases, employees may be eligible for retirement plans in multiple countries, raising questions about coordinating benefits and potential tax advantages.
International companies must also consider the implications of controlled group rules, which may require related entities to be treated as a single employer for retirement plan purposes. This can unexpectedly bring foreign employees under US non-discrimination testing requirements.
Challenges and Solutions for Cross-Border Benefits
International companies operating retirement plans in multiple countries face several distinct challenges. The interaction between different retirement systems, tax regimes, and regulatory frameworks creates complexity that purely domestic employers don’t encounter.
One significant challenge involves controlled group testing. US retirement plan rules often require related employers—including foreign affiliates under common control—to be considered together when applying non-discrimination tests. This can create situations where highly compensated employees in the US have their contributions limited due to low participation rates among employees of foreign affiliates who aren’t even eligible for the US plan.
Several strategies can address this issue:
- Establishing a separate plan for the US entity designed to satisfy the Safe Harbor requirements, thus exempting it from non-discrimination testing. Structuring the ownership of the US entity to potentially break controlled group status. Implementing non-qualified deferred compensation arrangements for highly compensated employees who face limitations
- Another common challenge involves employees who transfer between countries. When US employees transfer to foreign affiliates or foreign employees transfer to the US, questions arise about ongoing participation in retirement plans, vesting of benefits, and tax treatment of contributions and distributions.
- Currency fluctuations present another consideration. Exchange rate volatility can affect budget predictability for foreign companies making contributions to US plans. Some companies address this through hedging strategies or establishing US dollar reserves for benefit funding.
- Finally, coordinating a global benefits philosophy across countries requires thoughtful planning. Some international companies strive for relative parity in total retirement benefits across countries, while others adopt a market-by-market approach based on local practices. Either strategy requires careful analysis of the value of benefits in different jurisdictions, accounting for government-provided benefits, tax treatment, and investment options.
Best Practices from Foothold America
Based on our extensive experience helping international companies establish and manage US operations, we’ve developed several best practices for implementing 401(k) plans.
Start Early
Begin planning your retirement benefits strategy at least four months before your US launch. This provides adequate time to evaluate providers, design your plan, and implement necessary administrative systems.
Align with Company Culture
Your 401(k) plan should reflect your global company values while adapting to US norms. If your organization emphasizes employee financial security globally, structure your US retirement benefits accordingly.
Consider Your Growth Trajectory
Design your initial plan with scalability in mind. A plan that works for 10 employees may become administratively burdensome or cost-inefficient as you grow to 100 or more. We recommend building flexibility into early plan documents.
Educate Your Non-US Leadership
Many foreign executives are unfamiliar with defined contribution systems and their fiduciary responsibilities. We provide executive education to ensure your global leadership understands their obligations and the strategic importance of the 401(k) benefit.
Implement Strong Governance
Establish a retirement plan committee with clearly defined roles and documented decision-making processes. This governance structure protects the company and plan fiduciaries while ensuring consistent plan management.
Leverage Technology
Modern 401(k) platforms offer multilingual interfaces, mobile access, and integration with other HR systems. These features can significantly improve the employee experience and reduce administrative burden.
Invest in Financial Education
Many foreign nationals in your US operations may be unfamiliar with self-directed retirement planning. Comprehensive financial education programs increase participation rates and improve retirement outcomes.
Conduct Regular Benchmarking
The 401(k) landscape evolves continuously. To ensure ongoing competitiveness, we recommend annual reviews of your plan against industry standards for fees, services, and investment options.
Document Everything
Maintain meticulous records of all plan decisions, participant communications, and compliance activities. This documentation proves invaluable during Department of Labor audits or employee inquiries.
At Foothold America, we guide our clients through these best practices while handling the implementation details. This allows you to focus on your core business while we ensure your retirement benefits support your overall US strategy.
Conclusion
Navigating the complexities of 401(k) plans represents one of many challenges international companies face when expanding into the US market. While retirement benefits form a critical component of American employment packages, they exist within a broader ecosystem of employment practices, regulations, and expectations that foreign employers must understand.
At Foothold America, we help businesses with many areas of US employment, including 401(k) plans, payroll administration, healthcare benefits, employment compliance, HR support, and workforce management. Our comprehensive approach ensures international companies can build strong foundations for their American operations while minimizing risk and maximizing competitiveness in US talent markets.
For international companies establishing US operations, we recommend viewing 401(k) implementation as part of a holistic employment strategy. This approach includes aligning retirement benefits with the overall compensation philosophy, integrating them with other benefits offerings, and ensuring they support broader business objectives in the American market.
The success of your US expansion depends on building employment systems that work seamlessly together, comply with all applicable regulations, and meet the expectations of American workers. With the right partner guiding your journey, the complexity becomes manageable, and the opportunities become accessible. Foothold America stands ready to provide that partnership, bringing decades of experience helping international businesses establish successful US employment operations.
Disclaimer: This blog is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, financial, or investment advice. The information provided is general and may not apply to all situations. International companies should consult with qualified professionals, including attorneys, accountants, and benefits consultants, regarding their specific circumstances before implementing a 401(k) plan or making related decisions. Foothold America does not guarantee this information’s completeness, reliability, or accuracy. Tax laws and regulations change frequently and may have changed since the publication of this article. Foothold America is not a law firm, accounting firm, or registered investment advisor.
Frequently Asked Questions: 401(k) Plans for International Companies
Get answers to all your questions and take the first step towards a US business expansion.
Setting up a 401(k) retirement savings plan as an international company requires several important steps:
- Establish a US legal entity – You’ll need a US subsidiary or work with an Employer of Record (EOR) service to sponsor the plan
- Select a financial institution – Choose a provider with experience serving international businesses and understanding cross-border challenges
- Design your plan – Determine eligibility requirements, employer match structure, vesting schedules, and investment options
- Create plan documents – Develop the formal written plan that will govern your workplace retirement plan
- Implement administrative systems – Set up payroll integration, enrollment procedures, and reporting mechanisms
- Educate employees – Provide comprehensive information about the retirement savings opportunity, especially for foreign nationals unfamiliar with the US system
The entire process typically takes 3-4 months, so we recommend beginning well before your planned US market entry. Working with a partner experienced in helping international companies establish US operations can significantly streamline this process.
Foreign employers operating in the US must comply with several key requirements when offering 401(k) plans:
Legal Requirements:
- Plans must comply with the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which establishes fiduciary responsibilities and participant protections
- The Internal Revenue Code governs the tax aspects of your plan, determining its “qualified” status
- For plans established after December 29, 2022, the SECURE 2.0 Act mandates automatic enrollment starting at 3% with annual 1% increases
Testing Requirements:
- Unless utilizing a Safe Harbor design, plans must undergo annual non-discrimination testing to ensure they don’t disproportionately benefit highly compensated employees
- Controlled group rules may require related entities (including foreign affiliates) to be treated as a single employer for testing purposes
Reporting Requirements:
- Annual Form 5500 filing with the Department of Labor and IRS
- Regular participant disclosures regarding plan features, investments, and fees
- Timely deposit of plan contributions according to DOL regulations
The main options for meeting these requirements include establishing a fully compliant plan with strong governance procedures or partnering with an EOR service that assumes many of these responsibilities. Financial institutions specializing in 401(k) plans can provide compliance support, but ultimate legal responsibility remains with the plan sponsor.
Yes, foreign nationals working in the US can generally participate in workplace retirement plans, though eligibility depends primarily on their tax status rather than citizenship:
Eligible Participants:
- US citizens and permanent residents (green card holders)
- Foreign nationals on temporary work visas (H-1B, L-1, E visas, etc.) who receive US-source income reported on Form W-2
- Non-resident aliens with US-source income subject to US taxation
For foreign nationals, participation in an employer’s plan comes with special considerations:
- Tax treaties between the US and their home country may affect taxation of both contributions and distributions
- Investment account management becomes complex when returning to their home country
- Qualified distributions may face different tax treatment depending on residence status at withdrawal
Companies should provide clear guidance to foreign national employees about how 401(k) participation affects their overall financial picture. This may include helping them understand:
- The long-term implications of leaving funds in a US-based investment account
- The tax consequences of early withdrawals if returning to their home country
- How 401(k) participation coordinates with retirement benefits in their home country
A major benefit of 401(k) participation for foreign nationals is the ability to take advantage of employer match contributions while working in the US, essentially receiving “free money” toward retirement.
Structuring an effective employer match for your 401(k) plan requires balancing several key considerations:
Common Matching Formulas:
- 100% match on the first 3-4% of employee contributions
- 50% match on the first 6% of contributions (effectively 3% maximum)
- 100% match on the first 1% plus 50% on the next 5% (effectively 3.5% maximum)
Strategic Considerations:
- Align with your global compensation philosophy while being competitive in the US market
- Consider how market fluctuations might affect your budget if match is percentage-based
- Evaluate whether a Safe Harbor match (100% on first 3% plus 50% on next 2%) would benefit your organization by eliminating non-discrimination testing
Implementation Options:
- Per-payroll matching ensures immediate investment of matched funds
- Annual matching (contributed after year-end) improves cash flow but may reduce investment returns
- Performance-based formulas can tie additional matches to company success metrics
For international companies, we recommend starting with a competitive but manageable match formula that can be enhanced over time as your US operations grow. Document your match formula clearly in plan documents and employee communications to avoid confusion, particularly for employees transferring from international locations with different retirement benefit structures.
Managing retirement benefits across multiple countries presents unique challenges for global companies:
Key Challenges:
- Controlled group testing may require related employers (including foreign affiliates) to be considered together for non-discrimination tests
- Employees transferring between countries raise questions about ongoing plan participation and vesting
- Currency fluctuations can affect budget predictability for contributions
- Coordinating a global benefits philosophy requires analyzing the relative value of benefits in different jurisdictions
Effective Solutions:
- Establish Safe Harbor 401(k) plans for US operations to minimize testing complications
- Develop clear policies for employees transferring between countries
- Consider currency hedging strategies for predictable benefit budgeting
- Create governance structures that include both US and global perspectives
Best Practices:
- Maintain a retirement plan committee with representatives from both US and international leadership
- Conduct regular benchmarking against local market practices in each country
- Work with financial advisors experienced in cross-border retirement planning
- Document all plan decisions with clear rationales to demonstrate prudent fiduciary oversight
Many international companies find that professional employer organization (PEO) services or Employer of Record arrangements simplify these challenges by transferring much of the administrative burden to specialists familiar with multi-country operations.
Qualified distributions are withdrawals from a 401(k) plan that meet specific IRS criteria to avoid penalties. Understanding the general distribution rules is essential, particularly for international companies with employees who may return to their home countries.
For Traditional 401(k) Plans:
- Distributions typically become qualified when the account holder reaches age 59½
- Exceptions exist for certain hardships, disabilities, or first-time home purchases
- All distributions are subject to ordinary income tax, as contributions were made pre-tax
For Roth 401(k) Plans:
- Qualified distributions require both reaching age 59½ AND a five-year holding period
- Qualified withdrawals, including all investment gains, are completely tax-free
- This can be particularly advantageous for foreign nationals who may return to countries with higher tax rates
Special Considerations for Foreign Nationals:
- Taxation of qualified distributions depends on:
- The tax treaty between the US and their home country
- Their residency status at the time of distribution
- Whether they receive the distribution while in the US or after returning home
- Early withdrawals (before age 59½) typically incur a 10% penalty in addition to income tax
- Distributions to non-resident aliens may be subject to 30% withholding unless modified by a tax treaty
Foreign nationals should consult with a financial advisor familiar with cross-border retirement planning before making withdrawal decisions. Many tax treaties provide relief from double taxation, but the specific provisions vary significantly by country.
Required minimum distributions (RMDs) are mandatory withdrawals that account holders must take from their retirement accounts after reaching a certain age. These rules help ensure retirement accounts are used for retirement rather than indefinite tax deferral.
Current RMD Rules:
- The SECURE 2.0 Act changed the starting age to 73 in 2023, increasing to 75 by 2033
- For employer-sponsored 401(k) plans, participants must begin taking RMDs by April 1 of the year following the later of:
- The year they turn the RMD age (currently 73)
- The year they retire (if allowed by the employer’s plan)
- 5% owners of the business must begin RMDs at the RMD age regardless of employment status
Calculation Method:
- Each financial institution holding retirement assets calculates the required amount based on:
- IRS life expectancy tables
- The account balance as of December 31 of the previous year
- The calculated amount represents the minimum that must be withdrawn; larger distributions are permitted
Penalties for Non-Compliance:
- Failure to take RMDs results in a significant tax penalty—25% of the amount that should have been withdrawn
- This penalty can be reduced to 10% if corrected in a timely manner and the error was reasonable
International Considerations:
- Non-resident aliens are also subject to RMD requirements
- RMDs to non-resident aliens may face different withholding requirements based on tax treaties
- Account holders living abroad must maintain current contact information with their financial institution to receive RMD notifications
International companies should ensure their plan documents clearly address RMD provisions and provide education to participants approaching RMD age, particularly those who may have returned to their home countries.
The 401(k) plan, which became part of the Revenue Act of 1978, offers significant tax advantages that benefit both employees and business owners. Understanding these benefits can help international companies effectively communicate the value of their employer’s plan to US employees.
Tax Benefits for Employees:
- Pretax contributions reduce employees’ gross income subject to federal income tax in the year of contribution
- According to the Investment Company Institute, this tax deferral can save employees 10-37% on current taxes, depending on their tax bracket
- Investment earnings grow tax-deferred until withdrawal, allowing for potentially decades of compound growth
- The employee contribution limit ($23,500 for 2025, plus $7,500 catch-up for those 50+) is significantly higher than for individual retirement accounts
Example of Tax Savings: A employee earning $80,000 who contributes $10,000 to their 401(k) would:
- Reduce their taxable income to $70,000
- Save approximately $2,200 in federal taxes (assuming 22% tax bracket)
- Allow the full $10,000 plus any employer match to grow tax-deferred
- Only pay taxes when withdrawing funds during retirement (potentially at a lower tax rate)
Considerations for International Employees:
- Tax treaties may affect how retirement funds are taxed when distributions occur
- Employees planning to return to their home countries should understand how early withdrawals affect both taxes and penalties
- Financial goals may differ for international employees with shorter planned US residency
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, access to retirement benefits significantly impacts employee recruitment and retention, with 73% of private sector workers having access to retirement plans but participation rates varying widely. By clearly communicating the tax advantages of your plan, you can improve participation rates and help employees optimize their retirement savings.
International companies establishing US operations can choose from several main types of 401(k) plans, each with distinct features designed to meet different business needs and financial goals.
Traditional 401(k) Plan:
- Offers maximum flexibility in plan design
- Requires annual non-discrimination testing to ensure the plan doesn’t disproportionately benefit highly compensated employees
- Can include various vesting schedules for employer contributions
- According to the Investment Company Institute, remains the most common type, especially among larger employers
Safe Harbor 401(k) Plan:
- Exempts the plan from most non-discrimination testing
- Requires mandatory employer contributions following specific formulas:
- Basic match: 100% on first 3% of compensation plus 50% on next 2%
- Enhanced match: 100% on first 4% of compensation
- Non-elective contribution: 3% of compensation to all eligible employees
- Particularly valuable for international businesses with complex controlled group structures
- Bureau of Labor Statistics data shows increasing adoption rates among businesses with highly compensated executives
SIMPLE 401(k) Plan:
- Designed for small businesses with fewer than 100 employees
- Requires less administration and lower setup costs
- Mandates immediate vesting of employer contributions
- Features lower employee contribution limits ($16,000 for 2025)
- Requires employer contributions: either matching up to 3% of compensation or 2% non-elective contribution
Solo 401(k) Plan:
- For business owners with no employees other than spouses
- Allows both employer and employee contributions
- Provides higher contribution limits than most other retirement savings plans
- Can be useful for international companies establishing initial US presence with only one or two executives
Roth 401(k) Option:
- Can be added to any of the above plan types
- Contributions are made after-tax (not reducing current gross income)
- Qualified distributions, including earnings, are completely tax-free
- Particularly advantageous for employees who expect to be in higher tax brackets during retirement
According to research from the Investment Company Institute, approximately 60% of 401(k) plans now include a Roth option, giving employees more flexibility in managing their retirement funds. The Bureau of Labor Statistics notes that offering multiple plan features correlates with higher participation rates, benefiting both employers and employees.
When selecting among these main types, international businesses should consider their:
- US workforce size and compensation structure
- Administrative capabilities
- Budget for employer contributions
- Growth projections for US operations
- Global benefits philosophy
GET IN TOUCH
Contact Us
Complete the form below, and one of our US expansion experts will get back to you shortly to book a meeting with you. During the call, we will discuss your business requirements, walk you through our services in more detail and answer any questions you might have.
